Видео

I have seen most of the adaptations including a one hour tv show with a very young Charlton Heston. Each does some aspect of the novel well but they all make inexplicable changes. Overall the BBC miniseries with Timothy Dalton gets the most right and does the least harm to the original story by Bronte.

Japanese adaptation in 2015 is still the best, because all details for story really complete and love it❤

change the music in the background, its very disturbing

I want to see the 1995 fil with Colin Firth. I find McFayden acceptable but Kiera Knightly too young spoiled unattractive brat and to immature.

No god but Allah Islam way for peace and real monotheist Search about the truth with honest heart And first ask Allah to help you to find the way

God, the 1993 version sucked balls. Stayed away from the 2011 version for obvious reasons. Gene Kelly is always worthwhile but his version is only fair in justice to the book(s). The 1973-74 Richard Lester version is/are the greatest of all with only one failing - the principles are distinctly older than the literary characters - a minor point with how truly excellent the cast is overall - themselves a who's who of remarkable actors at the top of their game. Simply the best.

My favourite part of the 2004 movie is the caption showing the main part of the story happens in 1870 - a year when Paris was under a crippling artillery siege by the Prussian army and the citizens were starving, and five years before the opera house even opened.

Where is the cartoon version...that was the most authentic.

This voice sounds AI generated although i fear it is not. Unfortunately your comments and descriptions are spoken as if reading out loud a thesis paper on how to describe these movies without emotion. The Claude Rains 1943 version is a beautifully filmed and crafted piece of that period. The best Phantom performance is that of maximilian schell in the 1983 Production with Jane Seymour. The book is a dramatic thriller. Not a song and dance routine.

My favorite version of Jane Eyre on film is the one with Susannah York and George C. Scott (1970) with the unforgettable music by John Williams.

1996 film film plein de sensibilité avec des acteurs remarquables merci 😘

Gosh, the Phantom has suffered nearly as badly as Dracula, with many films being made that wildly deviate from the literary source material. In both cases we are still waiting for a truly faithful adaptation to bring the book to life.

I've seen 74, 93, and 2011. 93 is my faviorite.

Wow mam your video is too good ❤ I'm Indian ❤

I love watching the different versions and comparing them. I love the 2006 version for it's warmth!🔥 In the first fire when Jane says, "I am cold, Sir." And wraping his cloak around her, Mr. Rochester says, "Are we agreed you will never be cold again?". It's the magic moment when she realizes that she loves him. In contrast to St. John when she confronts him about his love for Rosamond, he says of himself, "...in my heart, I am a cold man". And when Jane says, "What's the use of 5000 pounds a year, if you can't lite a few fires at christmas?" I also like Bertha best in the 2006 version that she is still beautiful and treated with tenderness and has beautiful things in her chamber. She appears to be well cared for, she has bathed and her hair is curled. And the freedom she chooses when she jumps in the 2nd fire is almost an act of love, to free both herself and him from circumstances not of their choosing. Both Jane and Edward have felt the cold and choose to overcome and to be people who give warmth to others and not to deny warmth even to those who may not appreciate it. They are a true hero and heroin not victims of circumstance.

Rudyard Kipling actually wrote more than four Mowgli stories. There were eight total, but only three of them made it into The Jungle Book. But Kipling later published The Second Jungle Book, which included the other five Mowgli stories as well as additional non-Mowgli stories. The treasure chamber storyline is from the Mowgli story titled "The King's Ankus." Incidentally, two years after publication, Kipling decided he didn't like the way the stories were arranged, so he changed the books so that all the Mowgli stories were in the first volume, while all of the non-Mowgli stories were in the second volume. Unfortunately, most publishers today are either unaware of this or just don't care, because they go with the arrangement from the original publication. It's quite sad really.

There is 1921 and 1973 versions that were not mentioned

You forgot the 1967 film

Yes, the version of 2002 had been directed by SIMON WELLS ! a Great - Grandson of H.G. Wells. Fun Fact: As his famous Great - Grandfather he does not believe in " THE NATURAL SUPERIORITY OF THE CAUCASIAN RACE " as it had been common in his time, hence he used many Asian and African based people for acting in the movie. Just mentioning it because I heard often people complain about this talking about the 2002 version

EXCELLENT !! But there is a small contradiction. IF the Emperor asks the Veterans AFTER TEN YEARS for their wishes for their dutyfull service how comes her comrads in arms had served with her for TWELVE YEARS. as stated at the end. I guess the poem had survived the cultural cleansing in China when the DAO of Konfuzius became the State´s Philosophy because it helped to justify the costs for maintaining the GREAT WALL.

2009 Always

Jeremy Barrett is the best Sherlock Holmes forever.

phantom of the opera is my favorite musical and book, love learning about the history 😊

I like the 1940 adaptation of Pride and Prejudice! However, 1995 Pride Prejudice is the best

I ❤.. love stories! I love 4 adaptations of Jane Eyre!1943, 1983, 1996 & 2006! My favorite one is 1983 with Timothy Dalton and Zelah Clarke! However, I prefer the 2006 Jane Eyre ending!

GP and Jeremy Northam - best version

I have a Mr Dickins in my pants.

I love 1943 and 1983 versions. In first one I like the wolnerability, tha Wells brought on screen. In 1983 movie - closeness to the book.

The best "Jane Eyre" is 1983 version with Timothy Dalton and Zelah Clark! ☝😎

1974 perfection I have not see the TV movie & 2017 the soundtrack is sublime Susan Sarandon didn't do it for me but other than that I liked it & the death on the Nile remake for me it was meh, the original was so much better

Ruth Wilson is just perfect Jane.

1995 still my favorite!

I love Bbc version first, second version with Mia Wasikovska and third Franco Zeffirelli's adaptation, maybe most accurate and near at the book

Muppet Treasure Island is my favorite.

BBC 1995,the best,forever❤

Christine in 2004 is just about perfect. Her expressions, especially when OG reveals certain feelings, she never quite reveals what you want her too, she is just in stasis in a non specific innocent expression. As if she was in a state of purgatory. I wonder if that was intended.

Your video was beautiful and well appreciated. Thank you for your time and sharing your information

The best version in my opinion is joan fontaine and the marvelous orson welles.

2009 adaptation of course

2006 adaptation would be the best I've seen. The chemistry between Ruth Wilson and Toby Stephens was magical and it also went into the back story of Rochesters earlier life.

I don't like all of this movie 😢

Hi like the 1933 & 1994 versions ,they were very much like the book and the most autentic ,

The 1960s version is closer to the book, but some elements are absent from it. For example, in the book, Weena perished in the forest fire. The 2002 version was irrelevant and lacked any connection to the book. In today's society, leftist Hollywood media employs multicultural actors and actresses as political instruments to propagate ideologies such as feminism and racial domination.

I've seen the lot and I've just rewatched the Joan Fontaine and Orson Welles original B&W on RUclips. Honestly the rest shouldn't have bothered. Fontaine out-Janes all other Janes, and Welles out-Rochesters all other Rochesters. 💖

2:43 never looked that bad to me 😅

Hej Nora M. Dessa böcker är till dig från din vän Birgitta Windt, kram <3

Birgitta Windt som tyckte mkt om denna författare i sin ungdom, till Nora från mig.

I've seen the last three. And the 1974 version is the best by far. The book doesn't need anything added to it- it was that good a book. So why mess with genius.

I really enjoy the 2004 film, the Chandelier crash makes more sense as a cover for kidnapping Christine

The problem with the 2011 version is that at the end, Jane just shows up at Rochester's door and then the scene ends. It doesn't show the touching reunification scene. A big let down.